Other Treatments for ADHD

In addition to stimulant and non-stimulant medications, behavior management therapy can help your child with ADHD.

So most people know that stimulant and non-stimulant medications are available as treatment for ADHD.

But what else is available?

Other Treatments for ADHD

Wait, why would you need to consider other treatments?

Well, believe it or not, some kids can’t tolerate stimulants.

And others either can’t tolerate non-stimulants either, or neither work for them.

So what’s left?

There’s behavior management therapy.

In fact, although it is often overlooked, it is important to remember that behavior management therapy should be the first treatment for younger, preschool children with ADHD.

“There are many forms of behavior therapy, but all have a common goal—to change the child’s physical and social environments to help the child improve his behavior.”

Behavior Therapy for Children with ADHD

And even though older kids are often treated with medication, they too might benefit from behavior management therapy.

“Under this approach, parents, teachers, and other caregivers learn better ways to work with and relate to the child with ADHD. You will learn how to set and enforce rules, help your child understand what he needs to do, use discipline effectively, and encourage good behavior. Your child will learn better ways to control his behavior as a result. You will learn how to be more consistent.”

Behavior Therapy for Children with ADHD

Typical behavior management therapy techniques might include positive reinforcement and allowing your child to earn rewards for desired behaviors and withdrawing privileges to try and decrease other behaviors.

You also want to help your child:

Some children with ADHD may also need social skills training and behavioral therapy for help controlling impulsive behavior.

Once you find a therapist, you can expect it to take time for your child to master the behavioral therapy techniques and better control his ADHD symptoms.
Once you find a therapist, you can expect it to take time for your child to master the behavioral therapy techniques and better control his ADHD symptoms.

And of course, accommodations at school (504 Plan vs IEP) can also be helpful so that your child has extra time to take tests if needed, modified instructions and assignments, and extra break time, etc.

What About Alternative ADHD Treatments?

What about all of those “other” treatments for ADHD that you might have heard about?

At those homeopathic dilutions, it is unlikely that there is any real active ingredient left in the Brillia pills. Remember, homeopathy works by the law of the minimum dose and  although it doesn't say it on the label, homeopathic medications only contain a "memory" of an active ingredient.
At those homeopathic dilutions, it is unlikely that there is any real active ingredient left in the Brillia pills. Remember, homeopathy works by the law of the minimum dose and although it doesn’t say it on the label, homeopathic medications only contain a “memory” of an active ingredient.

Restrictive diets, vitamins, minerals, brain training, and homeopathic remedies that are basically diluted to nothing…

Nutritional lithium, probiotics, and digestive enzymes…

You are actually trying to help your child with ADHD, right?

If all you have tried are alternative therapies to try and help your child with ADHD, then it's time to talk to your pediatrician about some real treatments.
If all you have tried are alternative therapies to try and help your child with ADHD, then it’s time to talk to your pediatrician about some real treatments.

Then try something that at least has a chance of working…

And if nothing works, keep in mind that your child might not actually have ADHD. Maybe something else is causing their symptoms or problems, like obstructive sleep apnea, depression, anxiety, or a learning disability, etc.

More on ADHD Treatments

ADHD Medication List

What’s the biggest difference in ADHD medications?

Remember when we only had Ritalin, Adderall, and Dexedrine to treat kids with ADHD?

Know how many medications there are now?

Are All of the ADHD Medications Very Different?

Although there are a lot of different ADHD medications to choose from now, including some non-stimulants, it is important to realize that most of the stimulants are basically just different formulations or derivatives of Ritalin, Adderall and Dexedrine.

In fact, in many cases, it isn’t the ingredient that is different, but rather the delivery system.

Are your kids taking a short acting stimulant, that only lasts four or five hours? Or are they taking an extended release ADHD medication, that might last 8 to 16 hours? And if taking an extended release stimulant, are they simply taking one that mimics taking a short acting drug twice a day, releasing half of the medication immediately and another half 5 to 6 hours later? Or is it some other percentage on a longer, extended time release throughout the day, like the OROS time release system of brand name Concerta.

  • Adderall – mixed amphetamine salts – immediate release – lasts 4-6 hours – 5 to 30mg tablets
  • Adderall XR – mixed amphetamine salts – extended release with a 50/50 time release schedule – lasts 8-12 hours – 5 to 30mg capsules
  • ADHDnsia XR – methylphenidate – extended release
  • Adzenys ER – amphetamine – extended release liquid
  • Adzenys XR-ODT – amphetamine – extended release orally disintegrated tablets
  • Aptensio XR – extended release with a 40/60 time release schedule
  • Concerta – methylphenidate – extended release with a 22/78 time release schedule (OROS)
  • Cotempla XR-ODT – methylphenidate – extended release with a 30/70 time release schedule
  • Daytrana – methylphenidate patch – extended release
  • Dexedrine – dextroamphetamine – immediate release
  • Dyanavel XR – amphetamine – extended release
  • Evekeo – amphetamine – immediate release
  • Focalin – dexmethylphenidate – immediate release
  • Focalin XR – dexmethylphenidate – extended release with a 50/50 time release schedule (SODAS)
  • Jornay PM – methylphenidate – extended release
  • Metadate CD – methylphenidate – extended release with a 30/70 time release schedule
  • Metadate ER – methylphenidate – extended release with a 50/50 time release schedule
  • Methylin – methylphenidate – immediate release
  • Methylin ER – methylphenidate – extended release
  • Methylphenidate ER – methylphenidate – extended release
  • Mydayis – amphetamine salt combo – extended release
  • Quillichew ER – methylphenidate – extended release with a 30/70 time release schedule
  • Quillivant XR – methylphenidate – extended release with a 20/80 time release schedule
  • Vyvanse – lisdexamfetamine – extended release with a 50/50 time release schedule
  • Ritalin – methylphenidate – immediate release
  • Ritalin LA – methylphenidate – extended release with a 50/50 time release schedule (SODAS)
  • Ritalin SR – methylphenidate – extended release
  • Zenzedi – dextroamphetamine – immediate release

Do we really have over 25 different ADHD stimulants to choose from now?

Distinctions Without a Difference

Well, kind of.

For one thing, our choices of ADHD drugs to prescribe become much more limited once you realize how expensive these new medications can be, even if you try and use a drug coupon.

Price is a big difference on this ADHD medication list.
Price is a big difference on this ADHD medication list.

And again, our choices aren’t as big once you realize that most are really just different formulations or derivatives of Ritalin, Adderall and Dexedrine.

Can’t afford a newer ADHD medication for your child? Understand that many of these newer medications don’t actually offer all of that much benefit over older, less expensive medications.

Do you really need a liquid, chewable or ODT medication when most ADHD extended release capsules can be opened and sprinkled on food?

More on ADHD Medication List

What to Do About the Quillivant XR Shortage?

Quillivant XR is a long acting form of methylphenidate that is available in a suspension form, so is easy for kids with ADHD to take if they can’t swallow pills, at least it is when there isn’t a shortage.

Does your child with ADHD take Quillivant XR?

quillivant-xr-shortage

Then you likely hopefully aware that there is a shortage of Quillivant XR because of a manufacturing delay.

What Is Quillivant XR?

Quillivant XR is another stimulant that is used to treat kids with ADHD.

Like many other ADHD medications, the main ingredient in Quillivant XR is methylphenidate – the main ingredient in Ritalin.

The big difference is that Quillivant XR is an oral suspension or liquid form of methylphenidate.

What to Do About the Quillivant XR Shortage?

So what do you do if you can’t get Quillivant XR for your child?

There are plenty of other ADHD medications

You will likely want to stay on something similar though, which will mean another long acting stimulant with methylphenidate, such as Aptensio XR, Concerta (Methylphenidate ER), Cotempla XR-ODT, Daytrana (patch), or Quillichew ER (chewable tablet). Metadate CD, Metadate ER, and Ritalin LA are other forms of methylphenidate, but they only last about 8 to 10 hours vs the 10 to 12 hours of all of those other long acting ADHD medications. Focalin XR (dexmethylphenidate) would likely be another alternative.

Unfortunately, there are no other liquid forms of methylphenidate. Except for Concerta and Metadate CD, you can open and sprinkle the contents of these capsules on applesauce if your child can’t/won’t swallow pills though.

You can also try and teach your child to swallow pills…

Best Alternatives To Quillivant XR

In reality, you probably don’t have that many options.

Your child is likely taking Quillivant XR because he couldn’t learn how to swallow pills, won’t take medications if you open and sprinkle them on things, and didn’t tolerate Daytrana (the methylphenidate patch).

That still leaves you with a couple of good options, including:

  • Quillichew ER – a chewable form of methylphenidate available in 20mg, 30mg, and 40mg chewable tablets (was under backorder, but that seems to have been resolved)
  • Cotempla XR-ODT – an oral disintegrating tablet form of methylphenidate available in 8.6mg, 17.3mg, and 25.9mg tablets

The main difference between all of the different forms of methylphenidate?

Surprisingly, it’s not only if it is a liquid, capsule, or pill. They all have different time release mechanisms that affect how your kids get the medication.

Quillivant XR, for example, uses a 20/80 time release delivery system. That means that your child gets 20% of the dose immediately and then 80% throughout the rest of the day. Ironically, because it is only available in a pill that can’t be crushed or opened, the closest medicine to that delivery system is Concerta, with its 22/78 system.

Cotempla XR-ODT is close, with a 25/75 delivery system.

Quillichew ER uses a 30/70 delivery system.

Aptensio XR uses a 40/60 system and some others, like Focalin XR use a 50/50 system.

Why does any of this matter?

If your child was doing great on Quillivant XR and you switched to another medicine using an equivalent dose of methylphenidate, they will be getting that dose delivered to them differently throughout the day. While that might be okay, it could also mean that your child is now starting the day off with either too much medicine (watch for side effects) or is getting too little medicine later (watch for decreased effectiveness). And that will mean some extra fine tuning of your child’s medication until Quillivant XR is available again.

Is your child due for a refill of his Quillivant XR? It’s probably time to look at your alternatives until the shortage is fixed.

What to Know About the Quillivant XR Shortage

Quillivant XR is a long acting form of methylphenidate that is available in a suspension form, so is easy for kids with ADHD to take if they can’t swallow pills, at least it is when there isn’t a shortage.

More About the Quillivant XR Shortage

Choosing the Best ADHD Medication for Your Child

For the great majority of kids with ADHD, one of the many available medications will help to control their symptoms of inattention, hyperactivity, and impulsiveness. Learn how to choose the best one for your child.

There are a lot of options when it comes to treating kids with ADHD.

In addition to behavioral therapy, there are a number of different stimulant and non-stimulant medications.

How do you choose the best ADHD medication for your child?

Is there a best ADHD medication for your child?

What Types of ADHD Medication Are Available?

When DSM-II was published, in 1968, Ritalin had already been studied and was being used to treat hyperkinetic children with minimal brain dysfunction syndrome.
When DSM-II was published, in 1968, Ritalin and Adderall had already been studied and were being used to treat hyperkinetic children with minimal brain dysfunction syndrome.

Whether your child’s ADHD symptoms include problems with inattention, hyperactivity and impulsivity, or both, the treatments are the same:

  • Stimulants – Adderall/Amphetamine vs Ritalin based
  • Non-Stimulants – Intuniv (extended release guanfacine), Kapvay (extended release clonidine), Strattera

Remember, that although often underused, it is recommended that behavior therapy be the first treatment for younger, preschool children with ADHD. Both medication and behavior therapy are typically recommended for older children with ADHD.

Other off-label medications for ADHD that are also sometimes used include bupropion (Wellbutrin), tricyclic antidepressants such as desipramine (Norpramin), and imipramine (Tofranil), and modafinil (Provigil or Nuvigil).

Yes, we have come a long way from Dr. Charles Bradley’s first studies of benzedrine (racemic amphetamine) in 1937.

How to Choose ADHD Medication for Your Child

Once you start looking at medication options, the first thing to keep in mind is that there is no one single ADHD medication that is better than others for all kids.

The best ADHD medication is going to be the one that your child will take and which controls your child’s symptoms without side effects (or with minimal side effects) for as long as you need it to, without costing an arm and a leg.

So, do you want an ADHD medication that comes as a chewable pill, a pill or capsule that your child can swallow, a capsule that can be opened and sprinkled on food, a dissolvable tablet (ODT), a liquid, or a patch?

How long do you want it to last? 4, 6, 8, 10, 12 or 15 hours?

Is your child going to take it every day or just on school days?

What ADHD medicines has your child already tried?

Answering those questions will help to narrow down which ADHD medicine might be best for your child.

ADHD Medications

Again, there is really no one best ADHD medicine.

“…stimulant medications are highly effective for most children in reducing core symptoms of ADHD.”

American Academy of Pediatrics ADHD Clinical Practice Guideline

And you don’t even have as many options as you think you do.

While it may seem like there are dozens of medications available to treat ADHD now, most are really just different variations of the same few active ingredients.

And if you don’t have insurance or if you have have a high deductible, you will want to know that those that aren’t yet generic (in bold) are going to be much more expensive than the others:

  • Short Acting Stimulants (4 to 6 hours) – Adderall, Evekeo, Focalin, Methylin (chewable), ProCentra (liquid), Ritalin, and Zenzedi (often taken twice a day)
  • Intermediate Acting Stimulants (6 to 8 hours) – Dexedrine, Ritalin SR, Methylin ER
  • Intermediate to Long Acting Stimulants (8 to 10 hours) – Focalin XR, Metadate CD, Metadate ER, and Ritalin LA
  • Long Acting Stimulants (10 to 12 hours) – Adderall XR, Adzenys XR-ODT, Aptensio XR, Concerta (Methylphenidate ER), Cotempla XR-ODT, Daytrana (patch), Dyanavel XR (liquid) Mydayis, Quillichew ER (chewable), Quillivant XR (liquid), and Vyvanse (capsule and chewable)

  • Non-Stimulants – Intuniv, Kapvay, Strattera

In general, stimulants are thought to work better than non-stimulants, but again, there isn’t one stimulant that is consistently better than another.

And there isn’t one medication that targets specific symptoms better than another, so you don’t need to look for a specific medication just because your child has the inattentive type of ADHD vs another who is also hyperactive and impulsive.

Deciding Which Medication Is Best for Your Child

Which ever medicine you choose, you typically want to start at a low dose and slowly adjust the dose up or down as necessary based on how well it is working and whether or not your child is having any side effects.

“…more than 70% of children and youth with ADHD respond to one of the stimulant medications at an optimal dose when a systematic trial is used.”

American Academy of Pediatrics ADHD Clinical Practice Guideline

Keep in mind that:

  • generic, short acting Ritalin (methylphenidate) is often going to be your least expensive option
  • coupons are often available for newer medications to lower or eliminate your copay, but that doesn’t help you if you don’t have insurance, have a high deductible, or if a medication isn’t covered by your insurance
  • it often takes a few days for kids to adjust to being on an ADHD medication, so don’t judge them too quickly
  • it doesn’t take weeks or months for an ADHD medication to work, so don’t wait too long to make adjustments
  • if your child is having major side effects, don’t just switch medications, be sure to switch the active ingredient too. For example, if a low dose of Metadate CD made your child very irritable and caused trouble sleeping, then switching to Ritalin LA doesn’t make much sense, as they are both time release versions of methylphenidate. Other ADHD that contain methylphenidate as an active ingredient include Aptensio, Concerta, Cotempla XR-ODT, Daytrana, Methylin, QuilliChew ER, and Quillivant XR.
  • some of the newest medications, like Zenzedi, are really just different forms of Dexedrine, one of the first ADHD medicines.
  • Mydayis (mixed salts of a single-entity amphetamine) is just Adderall XR, but modified to a three-bead delivery system to make it last longer
  • Dyanavel XR is similar to Mydayis and Adderall XR, but contains a 3.2 to

    1 ratio of d-to l- amphetamine

  • you can open and sprinkle the contents of Adderall XR, Aptensio XR, Focalin XR, Metadate CD, Ritalin LA, and Vyvanse on applesauce if your child can’t swallow these capsules. The contents of Vyvanse is a powder and will easily dissolve in a small amount of water! These are often less expensive options than a newer chewable, liquid, or dissolvable tablets.
  • you can not open Concerta and Metadate ER or you will ruin the time release delivery system. They must be swallowed whole.
  • while there is an authorized generic for Concerta, there are some generic versions that do not have the same therapeutic effect because they do not have the same extended delivery system. Make sure you are getting an authorized Concerta generic.
  • some extended release ADHD medications simply mimic taking the medication twice a day, giving 50% of the dose in the morning and another 50% later in the day, like Adderall XR, Focalin XR, Metadate ER, Ritalin LA, and Vyvanse
  • other extended release ADHD medications have different time release schedules. For example, Concerta gives 22% of the dose immediately and then slowly time releases the rest throughout the day. Similarly, Metadate CD releases 30% of the dose immediately and the rest later. Aptensio XR uses a 40/60 delivery system. And Daytrana, the patch, slowly time releases the dose throughout the day. Quillivant XR uses a 20/80 delivery system. QuilliChew ER uses a 30/70 delivery system. And Cotempla XR-ODT tablets use a 25/75 delivery system
  • although some people start the day with an intermediate or long acting medication to get their child through school and then a short acting medication after school, before doing this, consider increasing the dose of the intermediate or long acting medication to see if it will last longer
  • non-stimulants are pills that must be swallowed and they typically must be given to your child every day for them to work properly
  • genetic tests to try and see which medications will work best for your child have not been tested on kids
  • even if you are only going to be giving your child medication on school days, be sure to give it every single day at first, even weekends, so that you can more easily see what side effects it might be causing. Otherwise, since it could wear off by the time you see your child after school, you might miss uncommon side effects, like if it made him too calm or more irritable.
  • being able to concentrate and do your work and not getting distracted and talking with your friends all of the time is not a side effect – it is the desirable effect.

Most importantly, know that you can take out a lot of what might seem like guess work if you have a good understanding of how these medications work.

What To Know About Choosing an ADHD Medication

For the great majority of kids with ADHD, one of the many available medications will help to control their symptoms of inattention, hyperactivity, and impulsiveness. Learn how to choose the best one for your child.

What To Know About Choosing an ADHD Medication

Updated March 2, 2018

Treating Hard to Control ADHD

Learn why ADHD can sometimes be hard to control and require more than just a quick prescription for Ritalin or Adderall, including adding behavior therapy, careful monitoring, and special accommodations at school.

ADHD is often much harder to treat than many people imagine.

It isn’t always just a matter of writing a script for Adderall or Ritalin and then have kids who had been failing suddenly jump to the ‘A’ Honor Roll.

ADHD Treatments

Whether your child’s ADHD symptoms include problems with inattention, hyperactivity and impulsivity, or both, the treatments are the same:

  • Stimulants – Adderall vs Ritalin based
  • Non-Stimulants – Intuniv (extended release guanfacine), Kapvay (extended release clonidine), Strattera
  • Behavior Management Therapy

Although often underused, it is recommended that behavior therapy be the first treatment for younger, preschool children with ADHD. Both medication and behavior therapy are typically recommended for older children with ADHD.

ADHD Medications

Surprisingly, there is really no one best ADHD medicine. Those that aren’t yet generic (in bold) are going to be much more expensive than the others.

  • Short Acting Stimulants – Adderall, Focalin, Methylin (chewable), ProCentra (liquid), Ritalin
  • Intermediate Acting Stimulants – Dexedrine, Ritalin SR, Methylin ER
  • Long Acting Stimulants – Adderall XR, Adzenys XR-ODT, Concerta (Methylphenidate ER), Daytrana (patch), Focalin XR, Metadate CD, Metadate ER, Quillichew ER (chewable), Quillivant XR (liquid), Ritalin LA, Vyvanse
  • Non-Stimulants – Intuniv, Kapvay, Strattera

In general, stimulants are thought to work better than non-stimulants, but again, there isn’t one stimulant that is consistently better than another.

Treating Hard to Control ADHD

What do you do when your child’s ADHD treatments aren’t working?

While it is important to “initiate an evaluation for ADHD for any child 4 through 18 years of age who presents with academic or behavioral problems and symptoms of inattention, hyperactivity, or impulsivity,” it is important to remember that not all kids with academic or behavioral problems have ADHD.

So the first thing you should do is confirm that your child really does have ADHD. Is it possible that your child was misdiagnosed and doesn’t have ADHD at all? Or could your child have ADHD and another co-morbid condition, including “emotional or behavioral (eg, anxiety, depressive, oppositional defiant, and conduct disorders), developmental (eg, learning and language disorders or other neurodevelopmental disorders), and physical (eg, tics, sleep apnea) conditions.”

Next, ask yourself these questions and discuss the answers with your pediatrician:

  • Is your child taking his medicine?
  • Does your child need behavior management therapy?
  • Are you not getting your child’s ADHD medicine because of how expensive it is? Ask your pediatrician about a lower cost generic ADHD medicine.
  • Has there been a sudden worsening of previously well controlled ADHD, which might indicate a problem with bullying, social changes at home, abuse, or depression, etc.?
  • Are you relying on restrictive diets or other alternative treatments for ADHD that have been proven to not usually work?
  • Does your child need a different dosage of his current stimulant, either a higher or lower dose?
  • Is your child’s medication wearing off too soon?
  • Does your child’s medication take too long to work?
  • Does your child need to switch to a different stimulant or to a stimulant with a different delivery method?
  • Does your child need to switch from a long-acting stimulant to a short-acting stimulant?
  • Does your child need to switch to a non-stimulant, keeping in mind that these are often used in combination with a stimulant and not by themselves.
  • Do you need to adjust your expectations for what kind of control you can get from even maximal treatment?
  • Does your pre-teen or teen with ADHD not want to take his medication anymore?
  • Are side effects keeping your child from taking his ADHD medicine everyday?
  • Does your child need 504 plan accommodations at school and/or an IEP?

And perhaps most importantly, what is making your child’s ADHD hard to control? Is he just still having some ADHD symptoms or are those lingering ADHD symptoms causing an impairment? If they aren’t causing an impairment, such as poor grades, problems with friends, or getting in trouble at school, etc., then your child’s ADHD may be under better control than you think.

What To Know About Treating Hard to Control ADHD

ADHD can sometimes be hard to control and require more than just a quick prescription for Ritalin or Adderall, including adding behavior therapy, careful monitoring, and special accommodations at school.

More Information About Treating Hard to Control ADHD

%d bloggers like this: