Have you seen folks trying to compare COVID-19 deaths to other things?
What other things?
Basically anything and everything, from smoking, drowning, and car accidents to the flu…
Those COVID-19 Death Comparisons
It’s not that surprising that those comparisons were made when the COVID-19 pandemic first got going.
But it is disappointing that some folks are still making these arguments.
“I’m not denying what a nasty disease COVID-19 can be, and how it’s obviously devastating to somewhere between 1 and 3.4 percent of the population. But that means 97 to 99 percent will get through this and develop immunities and will be able to move beyond this. But we don’t shut down our economy because tens of thousands of people die on the highways. It’s a risk we accept so we can move about. We don’t shut down our economies because tens of thousands of people die from the common flu.”Senator Ron Johnson of Wisconsin, chairman of the Senate’s Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs
What’s even worse, they seem to be using the arguments to discourage others from social distancing and wearing masks!
Fortunately, most people understand that you can’t really compare COVID-19 deaths to those other things.
It is like comparing apples to oranges. Sure, they are both fruits, but they aren’t the same kinds of fruits.
So why do some people make these false comparisons?
They do it to make you think that both sides of the argument are the same or are equal. After all, it makes easier to downplay COVID-19 deaths if ‘they’ can make you think they are the same as deaths from car accidents, drownings, and the flu, etc.
So why shouldn’t you make these comparisons?
For one thing, deaths from COVID-19 spiked suddenly. They haven’t been spread out over a year or many years, like deaths from car accidents, drownings, and cigarette smoking, etc..
“The demand on hospital resources during the COVID-19 crisis has not occurred before in the US, even during the worst of influenza seasons. Yet public officials continue to draw comparisons between seasonal influenza and SARS-CoV-2 mortality, often in an attempt to minimize the effects of the unfolding pandemic.”Faust et al on Assessment of Deaths From COVID-19 and From Seasonal Influenza
Also, unlike car accidents and drownings, COVID-19 is contagious.
And don’t forget, we go to great lengths to reduce deaths from car accidents and drownings, with everything from seat belts, air bags, and life jackets to fencing around swimming pools and laws against distracted driving.
Does anyone say “life is about risk,” while throwing their toddler in the pool and walking inside?
We make efforts to reduce that risk!
We also go to some effort to understand those risks…
“If we overestimate our risk in one area, it can lead to anxiety and interfere with carrying out our normal daily routine. Ironically, it also leads us to underestimate real risks that can injure or kill us.”National Safety Council on Odds of Dying
So what is your risk of being in a car accident?
Believe it or not, it is fairly low, with the average person filing a claim for a car accident once every 17.9 years.
And since only about 3 in 1,000 car accidents are fatal, the chance of you being in a fatal motor vehicle accident is also fairly low.
“The total number of confirmed COVID-19 deaths in the U.S. exceeds 115,000, outnumbering each of the leading causes of preventable injury death (58,908 preventable drug overdose deaths, 39,404 motor-vehicle deaths, and 37,455 fall deaths in 2018). However, the full impact of COVID-19 is even greater than the number of deaths and confirmed cases. The rapid increase in COVID-19 cases, the uncertainty regarding how long the pandemic will last and the disruption to normal everyday activities is impacting society like no other safety issue in modern history.”COVID-19 Cases in the United States
How does that compare to getting and dying from COVID-19?
Where do you live? Are folks around you wearing a mask?
If you are working from home in a small town with few COVID-19 cases, then your risk is obviously much, much lower than someone who works around the public in a bigger city with rising case counts.
Do you have any risk factors for a more severe case of COVID-19?
While the overall case fatality rate is about 1%, that starts to go up as you approach age 50 and is higher for those with many chronic health conditions.
Most importantly, what are you doing to lower that risk?
Just like your risk of dying in a car accident is going to be much higher than average if you drink and drive, don’t wear a seat belt, talk on your phone, and speed, your risk of getting and dying from a SARS-CoV-2 infection is going to be higher if you live in or travel to an area with a lot of cases, are around a lot of people who aren’t social distancing or wearing masks, and you are in a high risk group.
The bottom line though, whatever your risk, are you going to take steps to increase that risk for your self and those around you or are you going to lower that risk?
More on COVID-19 Deaths
- Comparing Lightning Strikes to Measles Deaths
- COVID-19 Vaccine Update
- How to Self-Quarantine After Being Exposed to a Disease
- Why Are Social Distancing Kids Still Getting Sick?
- Should You Be Tested for COVID-19?
- CDC – COVIDView Weekly Summary
- CDC – COVID Data Tracker
- COVID-19 Map
- Daily confirmed new cases (3-day moving average)
- Dr. Phil Downplays COVID-19 Deaths on Fox News by Comparing It to Smoking and Auto Accidents
- NEW: Perdue Compares Coronavirus Outbreak to Traffic Accidents: “A Certain Number of Us Will Die”
- Top US Health Official Rips Ron Johnson’s Coronavirus Comments
- Assessment of Deaths From COVID-19 and From Seasonal Influenza
- In leaked audio, Sen. David Perdue compares the risks of Covid-19 to car crashes
- How Many Times Will You Crash Your Car?
- Facts + Statistics: Mortality risk
- Opioids, Car Crashes and Falling: The Odds of Dying in the U.S.
- Odds of Dying
- COVID-19 Cases in the United States
- Mortality Risk of COVID-19
- If I become infected with the coronavirus, what are my odds of survival?
- Putting the Risk of Covid-19 in Perspective
- Microlives: A lesson in risk taking
- Coronavirus and the Fallacy of the False Dilemma
- Why smart people believe coronavirus myths
- The 13 Most Popular COVID-19 Myths and How They Emerged
- False equivalence and false balance – logical fallacies
- Science deniers use false equivalence to create fake debates
- The fallacy of “balance” and “fairness” about unscientific health claims in the media: A case study
Last Updated on August 22, 2020 by Vincent Iannelli, MD
You must log in to post a comment.